Oooh we gotta catch up. Been too long since I have given you all an update!
After army guy broke my heart and I was able to walk away from him despite how much I liked him, I realized that I have the strength to leave a man that doesn’t treat me right. It was a bit of an ah hah moment for me!
And it made me want a relationship again. I believe in myself now that I won’t allow myself back into anything toxic so I guess it’s ok to try again!
Ok so let’s go back in time a little. In May of 2024 I threw a speed dating event for my singles group. One of the participants was Benny. Handsome tall Italian man. Quiet. But charming. I was with C then so I didn’t think much of him. But I noticed how cute he was for sure.
Fast forward to June, we did a river float and Airbnb trip with the group and Benny came. But he had a girl with him. A girl he met at the speed dating event! I recall thinking “damn, he’s cute, too bad he’s taken.”I also kinda had my sights on someone else that weekend anyway.
Fast forward to early December. Benny was now single but I was dating army guy, which Benny didn’t know.
There was a post in my singles group telling people to leave their crush’s initials anonymously or as yourself.
Benny commented anonymously “I have a crush on (insert my full first and last name).” Benny doesn’t interact on the page much at all so this was a bold move for him. And I’m an admin so I can see who the anonymous posters in my group are.
So I dmed him and I told him I’m single technically but my heart is with someone else right now so it’s probably not a good time to date. I also told him I have always noticed him and if it weren’t for my situation, I’d definitely be interested.
He told me to let him know if it ends and if so, he’d love to take me on a date.
Fast forward to the Christmas party (Dec 14) with the army guy. This is in a previous post but he was hitting on my friends in a very ick way and even grabbed my friends butt.
So I dumped him the next day. It took every bit of strength I could muster but I did it! And I blocked him on all platforms because I knew if he reached out and had some big grand apology, I’d probably take him back.
When Benny found out I was sad, he sent me the song “Blue Ain’t Your Color.” A really sweet song about a guy saying she doesn’t look good sad and he’d never make her sad like the other guy did.
So cute right?
He told me he’s sorry it didn’t work out and I opened up to him about how much I liked that guy. I let him know I am gonna need a little time to heal from this one. I didn’t want him to be a rebound. I felt some potential with Benny.
He agreed. So we would randomly text from time to time and then shortly after NYE, we finally decided to go on a date!
I was really excited that the stars had finally aligned for him and I.
But then he threw a wrench in my fantasy! 3 days before our date, he messaged me and said there is something going on in his personal life and he had to sort it out before he can date.
I couldn’t believe it. All this anticipation and then just like that, it’s just over. I told him how important communication is to me and that I really need someone that can be vulnerable with me. It didn’t take too much convincing before he opened up and told me.
He said he takes medication for anxiety and he was symptom free for years. He thought his anxiety was gone so he weened himself off the meds. And now his anxiety is back. He said he’s getting back on his meds and will be better soon but he didn’t want to tell me because he didn’t want me to look at him differently.
I told him I was looking differently at him 10 min ago when he was going to push me away but that now I see he is self aware and doing what he needs to do to fix things and to let me know when he’s ready.
Next time I see him is at a group event. A country bar. About 8 of us went. We all got pretty tipsy and were dancing and having a great time. Benny and I were definitely flirting! And next thing I know I wake up and he’s laying next to me telling me he has to get home to his son. It was like 4am.
At this point, I start realizing I forgot some of the night. Fuck!
I just knew he was dressed when I woke up and he kissed me goodnight and left. So here I am thinking all we did was makeout!
As the day progressed, I started putting pieces of the puzzle together. I saw videos. I wasn’t sick or falling over, just having a great time. My friends told me Benny took me out on the dance floor at the end of the night and I don’t remember any of that.
By the end of the day, I was feeling the start of a UTI which was a big clue I probably had sex. So I asked Benny and he said yes we did. He was shocked I didn’t remember. Said I really seemed fine.
Well that’s me. I forget very easily when I drink. Apparently he and two other of our friends came to my house and we all had a beer together there after the bar closed. Then one left and the other crashed on my couch. I don’t remember any of that either!
According to Benny, I dragged him into my bedroom, sat him on my bed, took off my clothes and straddled him. He said I was very seductive and convincing. And honestly I’m not surprised. That’s totally something Drunk me would do 😂
I was disappointed in myself though. I literally JUST started saying I’m going to date with intention now and not sleep with guys right away. I told Benny I really wanted to wait a few dates before having sex and he said “Well then we can still do that. Let’s just pretend last night never happened and still take our time getting to know each other.” I appreciated him being so understanding and agreed.
So about a week later, we finally went on our first date!
So it’s Friday, January 17th and he planned the whole thing. He arrived at my door with the most beautiful bouquet of red roses. These weren’t no grocery store flowers. They were so lovely! I put them in a vase and then we left. He held the door for me and was just a complete gentleman the whole time.
He took me to a place in Livermore called Da’Boccery which had a bar, axe throwing and bocce ball. We had some appetizers and drinks and then we did some axe throwing. It was fun and flirty and we had a great time.
I know we kissed that night I got drunk but I honestly don’t remember it. I remember a small kiss goodbye but I didn’t remember making out. So when we were taking a break between axe throwing, he kissed me and it was lovely. I felt like “finally!” A short kiss but a little open mouth and tongue. I was happy to finally see how this man kisses and I was pleased. He held back a little. Like he wasn’t gonna full on makeout with me at a public place so I get it but I definitely wanted more.
When I offered to help pay, he said “No way. Never.” I was thinking damn, never?? I mean most guys will pay for the first date or two but after that I’ve always helped pay half the time for things. I wonder if he really means never!
We held hands on the drive back, which was nice. He walked me to my door and came in the hallway. We made out a little and then he said “Ok that’s all you get” and he left. He was gonna hold me to what I said about 3 dates!
I was worked up, I wanted to drag him to my bedroom again but I resisted! So I went to bed all hot and bothered!
To be continued. I still have more to share but this is getting too long!